Blue Mars
A review
©Inchoatus Group
May 2
|
|
Important InformationTitle: Blue Mars Author: Kim Stanley Robinson Publisher: Bantam Books Cover art: very consistent with the former books: nicely affecting for readers mulling over the story, but on the shelf a bit too much like a movie trailer Length: 761 pages in mass-market paperback (it keeps getting longer!) Rating6 out of 7 (More of the weird politics but elevated again by the informed imagination) |
|
Most Idiotic Reviews
“But with only a handful of well-realized characters, no plot, and hardly any incidents, what he’s written is more textbook than novel: a disappointment for readers anticipating a more resounding conclusion.” --Kirkus There were lots of clippings to choose from for this section. Perhaps the hallmark of a great book is the sheer number of people who misinterpret(?) it. Hamlet, for example, has seen its share if conflicting interpretations even around matters like Gertrude’s allure to various men. This idiocy from Kirkus shone above the rest, however, for its startling lack of reading competence. A bit shameful, really, for a professional reviewing publication. Claiming that Blue Mars is without incident is to wonder why Joyce chose such a boring, uneventful day for his subject in Ulysses. This is not a textbook. There is a great deal of incident. The living characters number in a handful but the dead linger still in their memories as fully realized as when they were alive in the pages. The conclusion is poetry. Whoever did this one for Kirkus is, without question, a pedestrian clod. We acknowledge it here to show that even the best reviewing publications are not without error… perhaps even ours. Most Accurate Review “[An] extended love letter to an imagined world and the possibilities it offers as a place to reinvent human society.” --Locus Many reviewers comment on the optimism of this book with Scifi.com making parallels to the Italian Renaissance and its portents for a modern society that lifted Europe out of the dark ages. But nowhere did a reviewer state the matter so succinctly. Reading Locus compare this book to a love letter to the future opened our eyes to the unshakable belief that Robinson has placed in humanity’s ability to make itself better and reach for the stars in glory and triumph rather than exploitation and viral reproduction. Robinson has poured that optimism into this book where it inculcates every reader who makes it to the last page.
What We Say
Blue Mars is a fitting end to the series and really could not have been better. While we do not nominate it now for a 7, as we mentioned before in our review of Red Mars, public acclimation may yet elevate it despite our petty quarrels with the politics and economics. Where these errors “bogged down” Green Mars, to borrow the term from Publisher’s Weekly, Blue Mars has ascended out of the technically accurate and somehow achieved a level of allegory and myth that permeates the entire work. Where before, characters achieved the mythic, now the entire setting has entered that realm—amazingly without loss of the technical merit and detail that has been the hallmark of the series. Because of its new foundation in the imagination, we forgive the economic flaws since it is a proper place to speculate on such idealistic issues. And as we noted above, he makes us believe.
The book opens with Ann. Still alive, still implacable, still attempting to save Mars. She deserves our pity. Old Mars, as it were, is now relegated to isolated, high-altitude or enclosed sectors that feel almost like aboriginal Americans herded on to reservations. Yet still she lives there, striving to preserve it as pristinely as possible, and continuing her research. Heroic Sax will continue to try and understand her and her motivations. Much of the book is devoted to this endeavor and it is one of the most touching plotlines in all science fiction to watch a human being devote so much energy and invest so much time only to understand another human being. Sax Russell, more than any other character, has become the ideal human in many respects.
The First Hundred are now relics as generation upon generation are being born upon Mars and remaking it into their home—no longer a colony but a nation. We see the political machinations now in a different light: not so much grasping for power but attempting to balance the various desires of its citizens. It is an example of human beings striving to actually “get it right.”
Earth is in peril: the flooding has caused many problems and Martians visit this planet for the first time and see how their efforts have become folklore back “home.” We see Earth rising out of its corruption and expend itself in longevity programs and further colonization. There is a striking image of approaching Earth with several space elevators spinning off the surface and we can almost feel the planet hurling itself into space with a last gasp.
We’re given long digressions about life, living it meaningfully in the face of virtual immortality, and how to continue to face death. We’re given a view of how people might choose to live in a place where technology has solved so many problems, the limits of human potential have been expanded a hundredfold, and the last inherited morals offered by religions have been shed (it is an atheist book in conception).
Best of all, we begin to see the colonization of other planets and moons. Each new area pregnant with the same possibilities and stories that were given by Mars. Each time the science merging seamlessly with the imagination and the myth. The Mars trilogy has never been about action, adventure, love, hatreds, or political conflict--though all of this is present. It has been about the human condition and the shape it will take as it goes through the crucible of truly “leaving the nest” for the first time in history. Robinson has finally reached the zenith of this sort of speculation in this, his final volume. While it lacks the urgency of Red Mars, while it suffers from some of the same problems of reality we find in Green Mars, it also seems that Robinson has at last found his voice and his vision.
Place in Genre Blue Mars, while in some ways better than Red Mars, will not have the same effect on the genre. As we stated before, no imaginative work—and probably few real efforts—regarding Mars colonization will be undertaken without feeling the influence of Red Mars. Blue reads more like a poem—a work to affect the conscience and the soul. It lingers in the mind almost as a paean to the Red Mars and the struggles that allowed humans to attain the promise that we now see in them.
Why You Should Read This People who doubted Robinson after Green Mars should not pass this opportunity. It is nearly required reading for anyone who has started the series to end it here. It is not a quick read and will require the reader to constantly pause and mull over issues. But it is well worth the investment. Such a beautiful love poem to space exploration should be missed by no one who is even casually interested in NASA's efforts. Why You Should Pass This is most definitely not a novel that can stand on its own. It can only be read with the background of Red Mars behind it. Of course, there are elements of Green as well and—while we wish it were otherwise—it’s probably necessary to go ahead and read Green first. Green is essential at least for the development of Sax Russell. People who are disturbed by free love, Socialism, and Nietzsche-esque disdain for the common folk have long since abandoned the series and will not be inspired to pick up this book.
|
||||||
|